Marco Island Homes with Non-Gated Community Type

Welcome to Marco Island, a shimmering gem nestled in Collier County, Florida, where the sun-kissed shores meet a vibrant community lifestyle. Known for its pristine beaches and breathtaking sunsets, Marco Island is the perfect place to call home. This charming island boasts a rich tapestry of natural beauty, outdoor adventures, and a warm, welcoming atmosphere that invites everyone to experience its unique allure.

In Marco Island, you'll find a delightful selection of homes in non-gated communities, offering an open and friendly environment that fosters neighborly connections. These residences reflect the island's relaxed yet sophisticated vibe, with many properties showcasing stunning waterfront views, lush tropical landscapes, and easy access to the island’s abundant recreational opportunities. Whether you’re seeking a cozy beach cottage or a spacious family home, the diverse array of architectural styles ensures there’s something for everyone.

Living in a non-gated community means you can enjoy the freedom of a more open lifestyle, where you can take leisurely strolls through tree-lined streets, engage with friendly neighbors, and take advantage of the nearby amenities. From world-class dining and shopping to exciting water sports and nature trails, Marco Island offers an unparalleled quality of life that combines leisure and adventure.

Whether you’re looking for a seasonal retreat or a permanent residence, Marco Island's non-gated communities provide the perfect backdrop for creating lasting memories. Come explore the possibilities and discover why so many have chosen to make this idyllic island their home sweet home!

Newest Marco Island Homes with Non-Gated Community Type

$995,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 226040288 MLS

Desirable western exposure, a private heated saltwater pool and beautifully updated interiors define this inviting three-bedroom, two-bath residence in a quiet residential setting on Marco Island. Designed for effortless indoor-outdoor living, the home features a new pool cage, new pool heated in 2024, expansive covered lanai and picturesque sunset skies, creating an ideal setting for relaxing and entertaining. Thoughtful improvements throughout include a new air-conditioning system in 2026, new roof in 2021, impact-resistant windows, a new sliding glass door, updated flooring and a new garage door. Inside, vaulted ceilings and new luxury vinyl and tile flooring enhance the bright, open living spaces. The spacious living room features a distinctive shiplap accent wall with a built-in modern electric fireplace, recessed lighting and expansive sliding glass doors overlooking the pool. An open connection to the dining room creates a comfortable flow for everyday living and gatherings. The renovated kitchen combines style and functionality with recessed lighting, a gas range supplied by an on-site propane tank, a built-in microwave, a wine refrigerator, a breakfast bar and charming breakfast nook. The primary suite offers a peaceful retreat with French doors opening directly to the pool area, custom closet storage and a renovated en-suite bath featuring stone countertops, dual vanities, tile flooring and a spacious walk-in shower. Two additional bedrooms feature plantation shutters, while the updated guest bath includes a new vanity, and a glass-enclosed tub and shower combination. Custom closets throughout and a laundry room with built-in storage add everyday convenience. Outdoor living takes center stage on the spacious covered lanai, complete with an outdoor television and ample room for lounging and dining. The heated saltwater pool invites year-round enjoyment, while desirable western exposure provides abundant afternoon sunshine and colorful evening sunsets. A separate fenced yard offers additional outdoor space, and the garage features custom cabinetry and ceiling-mounted storage racks for exceptional organization. Additional peace of mind comes from a newer roof, approximately 4-5 years old, and an affordable, transferable flood insurance policy. Ideally near Marco Island YMCA, Mackle Park, the public library and Marco Island Historical Museum, this residence offers convenient access to recreation, cultural attractions and everyday essentials. Marco Island's celebrated beaches, shopping and dining are just a short drive away. Combining modern updates, inviting outdoor spaces and an exceptional island location, this residence captures the ease and enjoyment of the Southwest Florida coastal lifestyle.

148 Cyrus ST, Marco Island

$1,599,999

4 Beds ⋅ 3.5 Baths ⋅ 226039531 MLS

PRICED AT LAND VALUE. Tommie Barfield knew this was an exceptional spot...and now it can be yours. Site of the Heights Hotel, the early Caxambas School, and home to James and Tommie Barfield, this premier homesite is laden with local lore and potential. Nestled in one of area’s most sought after neighborhoods, this property offers an exceptional redevelopment opportunity. The ample .47 acres is a corner parcel with direct access to Caxambas Bay just a short boat ride away. Featuring many mature native palm species, this is an exceptional canvas to create your own private, luxurious compound. Bring your builder and your dreams to take advantage of this phenomenal site, in the Estates of Marco Island.

1919 Indian Hill ST, Marco Island

$1,825,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 226040656 MLS

Your Marco Island waterfront lifestyle starts here—morning coffee overlooking the water, afternoons by your private heated pool, and your boat waiting on its own 12,000-pound lift. Beautifully updated and offered furnished, this inviting 3-bedroom, 2-bath home combines the charm of an island retreat with the added benefit of an established vacation rental history and future reservations already in place. Featuring 1,781 square feet of comfortable living space, the home offers an updated kitchen, refreshed bathrooms, and spacious living areas with sliding glass doors opening to the screened lanai. The private heated pool overlooks the tranquil waterway, creating a beautiful setting for relaxing, entertaining, and enjoying Florida’s indoor-outdoor lifestyle. A fully fenced backyard adds privacy and convenience. Significant improvements include a NEW ROOF IN 2025, NEW SCREEN ENCLOSURE IN 2023, and NEW DOCK AND BOAT LIFT IN 2018. With 80 feet of waterfront, a private dock, and a 12,000-pound boat lift, boating enthusiasts can enjoy the convenience of keeping their boat at home with indirect Gulf access for exploring Southwest Florida’s waterways. Ideally located just minutes from Marco Island’s white sandy beaches, shopping, dining, and Mackle Park, this beautifully maintained waterfront home offers an appealing setting for a full-time residence or personal vacation escape. For buyers seeking rental potential, the property’s established short-term rental history and future bookings provide an opportunity to continue an existing vacation rental operation, subject to reservation transfer arrangements. Whether you’re looking for your own waterfront getaway, an investment property, or a combination of both, this Marco Island beauty brings together boating, poolside living, thoughtful updates, and an exceptional island location.

1224 Shenandoah CT, Marco Island

$1,750,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2.5 Baths ⋅ 226040347 MLS

Exceptional opportunity on Marco Island! Situated on an oversized, western-exposure direct-access waterfront lot with an impressive 124 feet of water frontage, this spacious 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath residence offers 3,259 square feet of living area and tremendous potential. Enjoy beautiful waterway views, spectacular sunsets, and the flexibility to embrace the home's existing updates or create your own waterfront masterpiece. The interior features an updated kitchen with shaker-style cabinetry by EJH, granite countertops, wood-look plank tile flooring, and generous living spaces. A distinctive sunken living room accented by natural Florida coral stone adds character, while the spacious bedrooms, versatile fourth bedroom or den, walk-in pantry, and abundant storage provide everyday functionality. Outdoors, the pool area features a charming coral stone fountain overlooking the water. Additional highlights include an oversized garage, two-zone air conditioning, and an expanded floor plan incorporating an additional four feet along the south side of the home during original construction. An established vacation rental history adds another appealing dimension, offering the opportunity to enjoy the home as a personal retreat while also exploring its income-producing potential. With 124 feet of water frontage, western exposure, and direct boating access, this property presents a rare opportunity to enjoy today, renovate for tomorrow, or explore the possibilities of building new in one of Marco Island's desirable waterfront settings.

166 Hollyhock CT, Marco Island

$949,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 226040148 MLS

Welcome to 1217 North Collier, your private slice of island paradise on Marco Island! Kick off your sandals and step into this sun-splashed two-bedroom, two-bath pool home, where a bright, breezy coastal open floor plan spans 1,181 air-conditioned square feet. Gather around the large kitchen island that seats four, grab your morning coffee at the separate breakfast bar, and enjoy sleek stainless appliances while the living room looks straight out to the sparkling pool. The primary suite has a custom closet and an en-suite bath with a walk-in shower, perfect for rinsing off after a beach day, and the guest bath has a walk-in shower too. The guest room doubles as an office for when the island lets you get any work done. Out back, the south-facing screened lanai soaks up the Florida sunshine all day long, and the saltwater pool beckons beside a private, fenced, professionally landscaped yard made for lazy afternoons and golden-hour sunsets. Built in 1970 as a solid single-story concrete block ranch, the home has recently updated impact windows, a tankless water heater and gutters for added peace of mind. The one-car garage has an epoxy floor and custom storage for beach chairs, bikes and fishing gear, and there's no HOA. Restaurants, grocery stores and Starbucks are just around the corner, and the soft white sand of Tigertail Beach is close by. Make it your full-time home or a sunny getaway, or keep it working for you: the home has a history of good rental activity, professionally managed. Your island life starts here!

1217 N Collier BLVD, Marco Island

$1,365,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 226039270 MLS

First impression, curb appeal as you arrive, enjoying the homes on this beautiful street. This is an impeccably kept home showing pride in ownership. Move-in ready, offered furnished and only needs your personal touch. If entertaining family or friends, then the separate dining area, breakfast nook as well as counter seating will accommodate all types of gatherings. Kitchen is appointed with granite, stainless steel appliances and a large pantry. Plenty of windows and sliders not only bring in the Florida sunshine and brightness but comfort of impact windows and/or electric shutters adds to the worry-free living. The totally split floor plan is well designed, offering a pool bath with direct access to the lanai/pool. The pool has been resurfaced and the beautiful panoramic screens have been added to enhance the view of the water. For boaters, the canal is a water indirect waterway with a boat dock and 12,000-pound lift. It simply is a delightful home and centrally near shopping and restaurants. THIS PROPERTY IS BEING SOLD AS IS WITH RIGHT TO INSPECT.

349 Waterleaf CT, Marco Island

$2,329,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 226039662 MLS

Beautifully appointed and thoughtfully upgraded, this custom three-bedroom plus den, two-bath pool home captures the best of Marco Island living. From the moment you arrive, a striking custom iron entry door sets the tone for the craftsmanship and character found throughout the home. Rich woodwork, beautiful architectural details, and a timeless white shaker kitchen create a warm and inviting interior, while a tastefully renovated bathroom adds another touch of modern appeal. The flexible den offers an ideal space for a home office, additional living area, or quiet retreat. Outdoors, enjoy the Florida lifestyle from the comfort of your screened lanai and private pool, with highly desirable southern rear exposure providing beautiful natural light throughout the day. Boating enthusiasts will appreciate the private boat dock and indirect Gulf access, offering the opportunity to enjoy time on the water and all that Marco Island has to offer. Whether you’re searching for a full-time residence or the perfect island getaway, this home offers a wonderful combination of thoughtful upgrades, custom details, and the Southwest Florida lifestyle.

1195 Whiteheart CT, Marco Island

$2,399,000

5 Beds ⋅ 3.5 Baths ⋅ 226039640 MLS

One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged, AI generated or rendered. Welcome to this captivating Old Florida Charmer, where timeless coastal character meets modern luxury and the ultimate Marco Island waterfront lifestyle! Built in 1990 and beautifully updated, this exceptional 5-bedroom, 3.5-bath residence offers 3,488 square feet of spacious, light-filled living, breathtaking long water views, and quick, direct Gulf access for endless days of boating, fishing, and beaching! Designed for both entertaining and relaxed island living, the outdoor spaces are truly spectacular! Enjoy rare wrap-around porches, a tropical tiki hut complete with a bar, TV, and covered outdoor living room, al fresco dining areas, a refreshing swimming pool, and plenty of green space for children and pets. Boating enthusiasts will appreciate the 32,000 lb boat lift, making it effortless to head out for a day on the Gulf and return to your own private waterfront paradise. Inside, the thoughtfully designed floor plan offers an inviting open concept with beautiful water views throughout. The main level features two private ensuite bedrooms, a dedicated office, a spacious island kitchen ideal for entertaining, a convenient half bath, and a separate laundry room. Upstairs, additional bedrooms and a generous den/recreation room provide plenty of space for family and guests, while a private balcony overlooking the river offers the perfect setting to unwind and watch Marco Island's spectacular sunsets. Extensively improved in 2017, this home is beautifully maintained, exceptionally appointed, and offered completely TURNKEY! Notable upgrades include custom built-in cabinetry, motorized living room shades, plantation shutters, impact glass, and a new metal roof installed in 2024. The detached, air-conditioned two-car garage features attractive speckled flooring & abundant storage for all your toys, while the spacious driveway accommodates multiple vehicles. Just across the street, a neighborhood park offers additional play space, walking paths, and fishing opportunities. Best of all, shopping, dining, beaches, and everyday conveniences are just minutes away! Whether you're searching for a spacious waterfront family retreat, a luxurious island getaway, or a turnkey investment opportunity, this extraordinary property delivers the best of both worlds--classic Old Florida charm with the modern comforts and boating lifestyle Marco Island is famous for.

411 N Barfield DR, Marco Island

$739,000

226039637 MLS

This exceptional oversized lot is one of the finest beach access locations on Marco Island. Brief walk to beach access, Winterberry shops and fine dining. Take advantage of our design/build program to create your personalized piece of Marco Island paradise!

498 Fieldstone DR, Marco Island

$495,000

226039388 MLS

Build Your Marco Island Dream Home | Vacant Lot with Rear Buffer. The back of the lot borders a 50 x 80 foot buffer, so your future neighbor is open space. There's room for a custom home, a lanai, a pool, and a spa. Your blank canvas on Marco. Walking distance to the YMCA, Mackle Park, the Library, and the Historical Museum. Top schools, shopping, and dining are minutes away, and Residents Beach is under two miles. Spectacular sunsets. World-class fishing. Boating the Ten Thousand Islands, Pickleball, Tennis, The Beach, Dining, Golf and more. That's every day here. Marco is an island, and an island doesn't make more land. Vacant lots are nearly gone, and the ones left rarely come with this location and this much privacy. When this one sells, it's gone for good. Build your dream home now, or bank the lot for the future.

1398 Delbrook WAY, Marco Island

$4,600,000

5 Beds ⋅ 4.5 Baths ⋅ 226038915 MLS

One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged, AI generated or rendered. Discover an extraordinary blend of modern coastal elegance and waterfront luxury in this stunning new construction residence on Marco Island. Perfectly positioned on an oversized corner lot with coveted western exposure, this exceptional home offers nearly 3,600 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space, spectacular sunset views, and quick Gulf access to open water. Designed for effortless entertaining and sophisticated everyday living, the expansive open-concept floor plan showcases beautiful porcelain tile flooring, refined finishes, and elegant fixtures. The beautifully appointed kitchen serves as the heart of the home, complemented by a dedicated wine pantry and a distinctive interior wet bar featuring a convenient pass-through window that seamlessly connects indoor and outdoor entertaining spaces. Just past the dedicated den/office and half bathroom, the west wing of the house creates a private space for guests with a separate family room surrounded by three additional bedrooms and two full bathrooms. Thoughtful details continue throughout, including custom closets, a durable tile roof, 1000 gallon propane tank, generator ready, and a spacious three-car garage with sleek epoxy flooring. An additional enclosed storage room within the garage provides exceptional flexibility, with the potential to create a private fitness studio or hobby space. Step outside to your private waterfront oasis, where a sparkling pool with picture frame screen, outdoor kitchen and living areas, and breathtaking western sunsets create the ultimate island retreat. Boating enthusiasts will appreciate the brand-new seawall and dock, offering convenient access to Marco Island's beautiful waterways and a quick journey to the Gulf's open waters. Spend your days exploring the Ten Thousand Islands, cruising the coastline, or returning home to unwind as the sun sets over the water. Combining exceptional new construction, thoughtfully designed entertaining spaces, and the highly sought-after waterfront lifestyle, this remarkable residence presents an opportunity to experience the very best of Marco Island living.

328 S Heathwood DR, Marco Island

$4,750,000

4 Beds ⋅ 5.5 Baths ⋅ 226039228 MLS

Luxury waterfront living reaches its peak in this architectural masterpiece. This one-of-a-kind Gulf-access estate pairs timeless design with unparalleled custom craftsmanship. An expansive open floor plan maximizes dazzling SOUTHWEST water views from nearly every room. Sliding doors seamlessly integrate the indoors with a resort-style deck, heated pool/spa with a sun shelf, and lush tropical landscaping. The chef's kitchen features custom cabinetry, top-tier appliances, a 6-burner gas cooktop, and a pot filler. A grand marble staircase with wrought iron detailing leads to a theatre room, a cozy sitting area, and three en-suite bedrooms—each boasting a private lanai. Perfect for avid boaters, the property sits on a coveted deep-water canal featuring a new dock and a heavy-duty 30,000 lb lift. Enjoy hassle-free, bridge-free access to the emerald waters of the Gulf in just minutes. Countless custom details await—schedule your private tour today.

689 Rockport CT, Marco Island

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program (BR Program) of M.L.S. of Naples, Inc. Properties listed with brokerage firms other than this company are marked with the BR Program Icon or the BR House Icon and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. The properties displayed may not be all the properties available through the BR Program. The information provided is for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any other purpose.

Marco Island Homes with Non-Gated Community Type

Newest Marco Island Homes with Non-Gated Community Type

How much is your home worth?

How much is your home worth?